Personal Blog
Random assortment of essays, poetry, anything, and everything

​
I lay in my bed, idly. I find myself worried. Right now. Perhaps I should go back to Idle Hour and pay my bill that I forgot to get. Sometimes I still think about how close I was with people.
I’m tired. I want to probably just go to bed. Right now I look to my ceiling and think about the words we’d say, the moments we’d share, and the shit we would talk. I wonder how we would have evolved over the last however many years if we were all in the same place.
I look down at my death box. I scroll X and simply see everyone so upset, per usual. 4 years ago there were people that were inseparable from me, people I couldn’t imagine my life without, but I’ve had a full life without them now.
I ponder if I even cross their minds, as I read a racist tweet about two people simply dating and living their lives.
The cycles of life are beautiful somewhat. I just realized I forgot to pay my bill again.
In my dreams I can do anything. Though, I lay here in my bed stressed about food, money, and all the other things, I can’t help but think I need to go back to Idle Hour and pay for those chicken wings.
Idle By Tyler Justin Pruyn
I
I've fallen out of love-
-with this sketch.
You wouldn't believe what we were like back in the day,
but now I look and go, "It's fine."
So here.






By Tyler Justin Pruyn
FISH
Finding a way to show you that I care.
Looking back at the sea of others in this vast life seems endless.
Yet I still think of you.
The ethereal you that never leaves.
The you that you no longer are.
The I that I can never be again.
As time passes and the sea is recycled,
over and over and over and over again,
I think about everything that you and I were.
What was and what is.
​
I cannot help, but smile.
Because you and I are forever.
Even if we are not.
Home
Poems
by Tyler Justin Pruyn

Going HERE every Thursday
Going over the bridge in the same way
Every single one of those Thursdays.
Feeling tired, lethargic, in a daze.
Through all of this, Albany is home.
Summer nights riding in a bright
Orange Corvette. A check engine light.
Smoke billows from the burning washer drum.
A hot loogie on top, singing a loogie hum.
Albany smells like tires, loogies, and smoke.
4:30am dry cleaning pick ups and drop offs.
Up and around the mountains to truly wonderful lofts
Looking over the entire Bay Area. Though I am half asleep
I appreciate the wonderful quiet of the streets, shops, and homes. Not a peep.
Albany was informative.


Waking up to a chill down my spine.
In a large hand-me-down queen that is mine.
The perfect place to have money, loads of it.
Unimaginable egos, those will never leave and never quit.
Marin is Beautiful.
Cold mornings, cooler friends, life long
At least some of them. A song
Is sung of the wonderful fields of a state,
Roommates, lovers, and, most importantly, mates.
Marin had heart.
To the most important person in my life.
The one person who never caused strife.
The reason I go to Marin more than any other.
It’s clear who makes Marin, it’s-
Marin can be warm.


Around around around
Through the small cowtown
Away from "our" million dollar homes
But closer to to the cheap cheap Domes
Davis is kind.
The kind of place to create,
Without worry of how late
It can get when you go
To UoB after an improv show.
Davis is swell.
Swelling with a tear
Alongside all of my queer
And wonderful friends I had.
Even if some ended- poorly.
Davis was fun.

A Letter To Those Who Think It Is Easy
By Tyler Justin Pruyn
To Whom It May Concern,
​
Here we are again. For the first time in about 3 months I do not have regular work. Now the gig stuff was abundant at the start of the year, then I got a few jobs, and now I am back here. Which is certainly fine, but it is hard to feel that when I am not doing anything, which is quite alright sometimes.
​
While I am actively looking for a job just as I was in February and March of 2021, what I have now that I did not have back then is a foundation. I still have gig work, I have wonderful people in my circles, and most importantly, I am fully invested and engrained in some sort of entertainment scene in LA.
​
My room is also very put together, no longer have an oversized elliptical in it. Overall, I feel really secure in the kind of person I am. The most secure I have felt since the early months of 2020, when I was cocky and over confident.
Now, I just need to breathe and know I am doing a lot of things and have plenty of irons in the fire. It is just so scary, but that’s what life is all about, taking those scary moments, and you run with them and keep running until you can’t run any further than you have. Keep running. Keep going.
​
Maybe I don’t know how to write stories, jokes, or anything of use. Maybe I can’t do anything. Maybe this is all part of the process and I just have to be patient. Maybe that’s the vibe.
I don’t know.
I just know it sucks to be in between stuff and it somehow sucks the life out of the things you want to do.
One day it’ll all be fine and in comparison to last year, I am in a better spot and moreover the year before as well. Each year in LA has gotten better than the last. I just have to keep figuring it out, which is a wonderful experience.
​
But damn the 2023 San Fransisco Giants cannot hit.
"Sincerely,"
TJP
A Cover Letter.
By Tyler Justin Pruyn
In 2018, I applied to be a REDACTED at my college, the University of California REDACTED, better known as UCREDACTED. The REDACTED , some of which were and currently are my friends, were looking for someone to represent UCREDACTED as a whole. I was part of five extracurriculars, had good grades, and was, and currently am, an ethnically ambiguous person of color. The following is a cover letter that led me to a final interview with the REDACTED staff.
Address, State, Zipcode REDACTED
Phone Number REDACTED
EMAIL REDACTED
Tyler Pruyn
Dear REDACTED and REDACTED Staff,
The first time I came to REDACTED, I was with a friend that was considering attending. I was not. I had no interest in coming to this small cowtown. However, after going on a tour I was intrigued. After much consideration I chose REDACTED. Having been a part of a tour that changed my mind completely, I began to think that being a REDACTED for UC REDACTED was something I wanted to do. Due to a plethora of public speaking opportunities I have had, as well as my job experience, I am qualified for the job.
Whenever I have had work I always had to balance either another job or school. During my gap year, balancing a part- time teaching and full-time cashier job was my main focus. Having to balance all of this enhanced my ability to work effectively and efficiently in anything that I do. For example, one day I started one job at 4:30 a.m and ended the other around 9:00 pm. That taught me a lot about working through rough patches and persevering to be the best at either job.
Over the course of my youth, I had a theatrical as well as a public speaking background. These opportunities gave me the ability to feel comfortable when speaking in front of large groups of people. Never feeling awkward or strange whenever someone comes up to me for a question or a comment. I believe that these skills in tandem will provide for an effective REDACTED .
I am excited at the idea of this position and look forward to hearing back from you. Attached is my resume with a few other work opportunities I’ve had over the years that I had not discussed here. The best place to reach me is over email: EMAIL REDACTED
Sincerely,
Tyler Pruyn
​
This was my first ever cover letter.
My final interview, to my knowledge went well. A few days later, we were all informed. Unfortunately, my name was not on the list of brand new tour guides for UCREDACTED. One day, months later, I talked to REDACTED who informed me that she was disappointed I was not a REDACTED , though she was on the hiring team. I asked her why I was not chosen. She responded with one of the least helpful "criticism" I've ever received.
"Well some people, like me, really liked you, but others, not me, didn't like your personality at all."
I suppose more people did not like me.
Bi
The L and the W
It is quite funny
That something as
Small and meaningless
As baseball
Can make you feel
Poems. By. Tyler. Justin. Pruyn.
Echo
The peace at night
In the park just might
Be the calmest and coolest
And the most Los Angeles-est
Part of the city.
Wow.
Though it just might
Be a quite quiet night
For the most Los Angeles-est
Part of the coolest
Part of the big bold city.
Wow.
TIME
How the time goes
And it goes and it goes
Through the years
All of the many many years
Never in my life would I think I could
Imagine that the time fly like it could
Away away to somewhere I’ll never know
But looking into the past you'll know
Where it all went.
I hate you.
RUIN
I hope you are well
I hope you are okay
I hope you still believe
I hope I didn’t ruin anything for you.
As you did.
Even though through this rough patch
Even though through this horrible time
Even though through this time I hated you
I hope I didn’t ruin anything for you.
I wish you the best
I wish you happiness
I wish you still have your spontaneity
I hope I didn’t ruin anything for you.
But why do you get that ?
Does none of this matter?
And you never get to know that
I didn’t ruin anything for you.
Mic
Check check check.
Is this thing in?
On*
Sorry !
Auto correct.
:-/
However, while recently reflecting over his death in the last nine months or so, an interview I had done with Bowie a little more than a year ago reemerged on my desktop. I was lucky enough to interview him due to a mutual friend. I had interviewed many famous and infamous rockers from those times, but never Bowie. He was gracious enough to allow me in his home. The interview tells the story of Bowie in his older age, who was able to reflect on his own youth and lengthy career. He was not as flashy, exuberant, or bright as the coked out Ziggy Stardust of the 70’s, but what replaced him was a wonderfully wise sixty-eight year old with a certain gleam in his mismatched eyes.
​
June 28th, 2015
MT: Thanks for allowing me to meet you here. I know you don’t really-
Bowie: It’s quite alright. I’ve managed to stay out of it all in my latter years, but one here and there is fine. Decent in fact.
MT: Cheers. I’ll start with the obvious, do you miss the limelight? You were arguably the biggest star of the 70’s and 80’s.
Bowie(Laughing): No, no, not in the slightest. But I allowed you here today because I suppose it’s more of the idea… the notion that I enjoy a good chat between two people, man, woman, what have you. I like a good chat, a great deal. There are many people on Earth. Just the concept of all of us living on the same planet, and not getting the opportunity to talk to each person is somewhat sad. So, when I get the chance to talk to someone I hadn’t before, it seems fine, pretty decent in fact. (Bowie grins.)
MT: I see. It must feel good to have your work seen by millions and billions of people on this planet.
Bowie: Sure. In a way I have the ability to speak to people I haven’t and will never meet in my lifetime. Somewhat sad, but the truth. Had a great deal of fun performing. Before the heart attack of course. But it was something I felt I was good at and I could connect to others in that way because of it. Real dionysian ecstasy of the seventies. Free love… all that.
MT: Interesting times. You absolutely had no fear in the seventies.
Bowie: There’s always fear with anything you do. Some sort of inherent fear of doing the “weird.” It’s wonderful though. I loved that portion. Some queerness, gayness that I absolutely had a blast with. Old Ziggy Stardust. Would never work today. I’m much too old.
MT: Did you ever feel as if your sexuality defined you as an artist? As a musician at that time it felt like people could be flamboyant, but as a solo act I feel as if it’s different. Were you ever afraid?
Bowie: Somewhat. I mean John and Mercury were essentially solo acts that were as flamboyant if not more so than me. Not that it’s a competition. We were all fantastic. I felt as if the sexuality wasn’t defining me as much as my own music did. It still does. There was this idea of masculinity that was harvested after World War II. Mainly surrounding the idea of the nuclear family. The concept that every family should have a man, woman, and child. A kind of idyllic view of family and love. The man is out working, the wife cooks and cleans at home, and the child male or female would learn the domestic stereotypes of their parents. It’s all bullshit, but it was something people found themselves tied to. That’s where masculinity of it all comes in. This idea that masculinity was defined by males. These bland men were the form of masculinity and male toughness that society would be attracted to.
MT: But you didn’t do that.
Bowie: I’m not boring. At least not that boring. It wasn’t that I chose any of this either. I just had a desire to do so, as many have a desire to be boring. (He smirked here). I once read in a bookI found named Female Masculinity that there is, “ a crucial relationship between language and desire such that language structures desire and express… both the fullness and the futility of human desire”(Halberstam 8). So just as the nuclear family was created due to a backlash from a world war, desire arose, and has always done so, through the lens of a relationship with the structure of society. Desire as well as the stereotypes could not have been created without language, otherwise we would just be all extinct by now or living in a meaningless society. No structure. No nothing. At the end of the day these desires manifest the type of person we become, whether it be straight, gay, bisexual, or what have you.
MT: It wasn’t a choice to be different and performative?
Bowie: I mean it’s as much of a choice as how you present yourself, but I wanted to be bold and brash, and maybe a tad too fascist at the time, but without my desire back then, I couldn’t have truly found the niche that I did.
MT: Quite the large niche.
Bowie: It was. I felt like it was something that had to be done at some point. I had grown tired of seeing people in a post WWII world be tied down by such boring desires. Growing up, seeing the Beatles with their straight-edge bowl cuts and tight suits or Elvis with the big hair and tight suit. It was all very masculine. I somewhat played on that in “Boys Keep Swinging.”
MT: That got a lot of backlash.
Bowie: Who thought dressing like a 50’s heartthrob like Elvis would do that?
MT: That’s not the part of the video many had a problem with. It’s the lack of masculinity in the chorus.
Bowie: Is that right? I didn’t find that at all less masculine than the verse. In my eyes, “affirmations begin not by subverting masculine power or taking up a position against masculine power but by turning a blind eye to conventional masculinities and refusing to engage” (Halberstam 9). I felt as if I was not negating masculinity by dressing in drag, but perhaps seeing a new masculinity. Perhaps a female masculinity. The final woman that comes out in that video is incredibly regal. There is a wonderful sense of masculinity in that. The epitome of female masculinity, in my eyes, maybe not to others. But that’s the beauty of it all.
MT: The beauty of what?
Bowie: The beauty of masculinity. It has the ability it be looked at in different ways. Much like paintings by Pollock, there seems to be so many different ways to look at it. Look at everything. At least that’s what I gathered from the Halberstam book I read.
MT: And you tried to put that in your work?
Bowie: You can look at it that way. There are so many ways to be and I think I reflected that in most of my work. If you look at it all. I tried to do a lot. Still doing a good amount in my older age.
MT: I feel as…. Oh never mind.
Bowie: No no what were you going to say?
MT: Well… I was… don’t take offense to this, but I was never the biggest fan of yours growing up. Still not quite sure why…. But maybe it felt like you had too many ideas going on-
Bowie: Because of my divirsety?
MT: Precisely the differences in music, melody, all of that-
Bowie: I feel as if you haven’t looked into it enough.
MT: I assure you I have.
Bowie: There’s subtleties throughout most, if not all, of my works that connect them. They’re all very much akin to one another.
MT: How so? “Oh! You Pretty Things” and ''Quicksand” for example seem incredibly different. Even though they’re both from your early work. Don’t even get me started on those in relation to something like “Golden Years,” which is much more funk than anything else. Quite frankly it feels all over the place.
Bowie: I think if you look at the lyrics and see, most of these songs can be connected to Nietzsche. His philosophy has been influenced throughout my life and into my older age. All of my lyrics are quite nihilistic.
MT: Most of them are upbeat.
Bowie: Doesn’t mean they’re bloody optimistic now does it?
MT: I mean-
Bowie: I won’t dive into my own music and spell out for you, but all the songs you listed have rather provocative pessimistic lyrics. “Don’t believe in yourself, don't deceive with belief.”
MT: “Knowledge comes with….” Right well you’re-
Bowie: It all comes from Nietzchian philosophy. The dionysian and apollonian. In The Birth of Tragedy he explains these contrasting ideas. Apollonian is much more individual while dionsyian bliss is similar to say a crowd at a concert. Dionsyian is all about that ecstasy.
MT: What does this have to do with nihilism?
Bowie: I’m introducing you to his philosophy. It’s all connected in someway. This ties into why people, unlike you, followed me. My music was incredibly dionsyian in those days. It had a feeling of drunkenness and ecstasy. That’s the music part, right? The “upbeat” as you so eloquently put it earlier, yes?
MT: Right.
Bowie: Now my lyrics are much more nihilistic, which is this idea that nothing really matters as it is currently. “Don’t believe in yourself” all of that. There’s this story that I adore from one of his writings, The Gay Science. It goes, “A demon… [says]: 'This life as you now live it and have lived it you will have to live once again and innumerable times again; and there will be nothing new in it, but every pain and every joy”(Nietzsche 194). And he tells you this. This idea is both terrifying and lovely. As I age and get older, which is something I am constantly working through I might add, I find myself revisiting this story. I think about the last breath I’ll take and where I may very well reset my life, all the way from the beginning. It’s truly a fascinating concept. And well would you do that? Would you like to know that you live your life over and over again or simply live in blissful ignorance of what happens next?
MT: I’m not sure.
Bowie: It’s a very nihilistic view of the world. That we live this boring and futile life for eternity but we don’t know it. It’s a circle. So in my eyes that’s precisely the reason I stay diverse. Even if I live an eternity in the same life, my choices are at least somewhat interesting. These ideas of nihilism are ingrained in my lyrics. The very concept of a song is this. You have verses, but you are continually finding yourself saying the same chorus for eternity.
MT: Eternity can be frightening.
Bowie: Terrifying. Quite right, but it's refreshing to know that my music might very well live onto that. True eternity, not a cyclical one. I’m not some young Ziggy Stardust anymore. My time is surely coming.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
MT: Are you okay with that?
Bowie: In some ways I am. In some ways I’m not. I’m sure you’ll go back through all of this and see how much I’ve contradicted myself. But as of now, I feel pretty good about it all. I mean what do I have to fear? Nietzche famously said God is dead and, “We have killed him”(Nietzche 120). It’s not so much that we actually killed God, but the fact that we have killed him through our sinful actions. It is time to create something new, which could be a plethora of different occurrences, but it’s for ourselves to decide, whatever we feel is the best way possible.
MT: How do you do that, David?
Bowie: I like to think I do that through my work, I strive for diversity.
MT: It’s interesting that you’ve kept discussing the idea of diversity as a white man you haven’t got much.
Bowie: (He smiles) I’d like to imagine the diversity in my work is different than my ideology on race. I think everyone should be equal, I suppose. We’re all homosapiens on this rotating orb.
MT: What about the “Young Americans” era of music?
Bowie: What about it?
MT: Lot of it came from African-American funk.
Bowie: I don’t think I was stealing if that’s what you’re insinuating. This is why I don’t like to discuss things like this. Frankly, I’m not terribly in love with a lot of those songs anymore. Therein that’s the reason I don’t play them anymore.
MT: I find that portion of your career probably the most fascinating as it is truly different, in my eyes. Everything seems as if it is ripping off black culture, honestly. Margo Jefferson wrote once that, “Elvis Presley was the greatest minstrel America ever spawned, and he appeared in bold whiteface”(Jefferson 50). I am not here to say that you were a minstrel throughout your career, but “Young Americans” seems as if you were almost doing the exact thing that Elvis was doing. It’s not like he had to have blackface on, it was more the style of his music. He took some songs and danced like blacks without giving any credit. Furthermore-
Bowie: Hold on. What is this about? Me? Or Elvis? Are you trying to get me to admit something that’s false?
MT: Is it?
Bowie: I believe that one can be inspired by other races and artists. I never look at any of my songs as solely my own creation. There’s a line from The Beatles in “Young Americans.” I’ve only wanted equality and when I came to America, I was fascinated by all of the diversity here.
MT: It seems like a strange jump to make from one album to the next and that’s not even discussing your facisit era.
Bowie: It’s about diversifying my portfolio. I try a little this and that, but it’s all for the love of music. I find myself constantly changing and challenging myself. I’ve always wanted equality for all people as well. I wanted to show the world that it is okay to be different and in fact it is wonderful. In “Heroes” I suggest that “we can be heroes just for one day.” Whatever that means to you. If we can love one another-
MT: That’s very nice of you to say but-
Bowie: Listen, I think we’ve gone off track a tad. I’m not a minstrel as you might be insinuating. More recently, I’ve been reading this new book that’s all about the concept of “black nihilism” this is different than my early discussion as it focuses on black society and self more so than one’s own personal ideology about the world. There’s a lot of rejection in this. The author Warren writes that, “To refuse to “do politics” and to reject the fantastical object of politics is the only “hope” for blackness in an anti-black world.” This is what you’re doing now. Rejecting my notion of inspiration. I just think his claims and your claims are bullshit. I think that black nihilism in general is an important concept. The idea that these people have been persecuted and tortured for so long and that there is no solution today. Just three years ago, Trayvon Martin was murdered and his murderer got off scot-free just as the Till murderers nearly six decades before. The solution stated in this book is to reject all of it. I don’t think you could get anywhere with that. That’s not my idea of nihilism of any sort. There is some sort of solution in creating something new and wonderful. That is what we should strive for here. I’m not taking so much as creating something new. Something that incorporates some of this and that. People want to create something new. That’s different for everyone, but for me, it is through my own music and how I presented myself and continue to present myself.
MT: And how’s that, David?
Bowie: It’s strange- weird- I feel like I wanted to engage the public in a different way than most rockstars did. Not through my masculinity, but through my strange performances and outlandish sets. How I wish to live my life for eternity is like that. And there’s some acceptance to my weirdness in that. Love too.
​

October 1st, 2016
David Bowie was never the type of musician I particularly followed during my youth. He was flashy, exuberant, and bright but for my own money he never quite felt like “rock n’ roll” to me. I found myself entranced by The Rolling Stones, Led Zeppelin, or Queen. Rarely Bowie. Those bands felt like the essence of rock n’ roll. I knew all their names, instruments, and estranged lovers. They felt like this, while Bowie was well Bowie.
​
By Tyler
Justin Pruyn
A final creative
project for a
Critical Theory
course
The Exuberant Bowie

October 1st, 2016
There was a wonderful passion in Bowie that I could never see as a child. All I saw was a lost rocker, but in reality he knew what he was doing. He was doing something different and wonderful. Something not done before. It wasn’t until after his recent death that I truly started thinking about it. The strangest part is that Bowie was never angry with me during this interview. He was simply loving. He was to the point. It wasn’t an argument near the end, but a discourse.
As I replay this day in my head, I think of his flashiness, wisdom, brightness, and his exuberance. Throughout this interview nearly seven months before he passed on. Leaving this world to start his life over again and live it in the diverse and queer way he will always.

Three Really Short Stories
By Tyler Justin Pruyn
Baby’s First Words
“Momma,” the baby spewed out her first words.
“Get the fuck out of here,” her mother told her father.
“Bababa,” the baby retorted.
Her father fired back,“Very mature, please tell me again how wrong I was when you fucked Stanley in our home!”
“Momma” the baby repeated.
Her mom warned, “ you’re never going to find someone like me-“
“Alamamala”
“-I don’t need you in my life anymore-“
“You’re a piece of shit, maybe think about how Stan made me feel- what he reminded me of- how you don’t- can’t give affection-“
“Chalalalaal”
“-this isn’t-“
“This has everything to do-“
“Don’t fucking go there you fucking cheater-you bitch- I loved you-“
“We can discuss this all we want but this comes back to your-“
“Momma!” The baby yelled.
The couple stopped.
“Sorry.”
The Rest Was History
Glarg glared toward the end of the cave.
“Could it be?” He thought, but could only muster a “oogalooo!“ that echoed throughout his home.
Fuppell appeared from the end of the cave with two rocks in hand. “You’re devilishly curious of this new invention I’ve discovered I’m sure dear sport!” Fuppell thought with a smirk, though all that came about was a lowly “chaloco darkini!”
The two cave people laughed for a moment then stopped.
It was time.
Glarg dragged over the leaves that he had gathered earlier in the day for this occasion. Fuppell stood back, raised the two pieces of rock over his head….
Click.
Nothing.
Click.
Nothing.
Click.
A spark.
It caught on the leaves and bloomed. Fuppell smiled, “There dear boy. I’ve miraculously done the impossible. A brand new element that will certainly assist us in all of our necessities. It provides light, keeps us warm, and will make the fish taste delectable let me tell you.”
Though he actually simply stated, “fire.”
Appreciation Post
Courtney looked at those eyes. They were baggy, dull, and dead. She was exhausted. She wiped the makeup off of that face.
Finally it’s over.
Her 15th day of working in a row.
“Congrats,” her manager told her that day, “we really appreciate the effort you’ve put in.” It rang through her head over and over again. “Effort.” “you’ve.” “Put. In.”
A small amount of appreciation was given to her.
Great.
She watched herself in the mirror. An onlooker.
This was not her. This was not the child that killed the Cinderella audition and destroyed the role of the Fairy Godmother. Nor the teenager that took over five virginities, including her best friend Mimi’s. And no, this was not the early 20’s woman that came to New York to make a name for herself. “An impressive specimen,” her dad would always jokingly call her.
Though, it was not her in the mirror.
It was not someone to be impressed by.
It was simply a waiter that put in effort.
THE WALKING DEAD
And The Problem With Modern Media
By Tyler Justin Pruyn

PART I: DAYS GONE BYE
In my youth, I was scared of most things. Steps in the night, a creaky door, a janitor with blades for hands the thought of any of those would send shivers down my spine. I would hate my pitch black room, the endless corners, and mostly scary movies. However, one of the first loves of my young adolescent life was something gory, disgusting, and, yes, scary.
​
The Walking Dead was developed in 2010 with thanks to Frank Darabont. After reading the on-going 2003 comic series of the same name, penned by Robert Kirkman and drawn by Charlie Adler, Darabont along with AMC, who was just starting the golden age of television with Breaking Bad and Mad Men, was set to adapt the material.
​
After a successful six-episode first season, I caught up in the same room where I hid underneath the blanket wishing Freddy Krueger would not find me. It was different and new for me to genuinely enjoy something scary, like the undead coming to eat me. Though I was scared for most of the first seasons, the characters made all the difference. The ensemble of the series truly made it special. It created a safe space where the leads of the series could protect me from those walkers that try to eat me in the night. Over the rest of my middle school and high school career I slowly caught up on the comic series, while watching the show. That boy that would hide under the covers was nowhere to be seen. In many ways The Walking Dead is a huge reason in my development from childhood to adulthood.
​
In Summer of 2019, I was sitting in an “interpersonal relationships” college course when I was surfing the internet and saw that issue #193 of The Walking Dead, coming out tomorrow, would in fact be the final issue of the sixteen year long series. I was shocked. The next day I ran to my local comic store and, of course, issue #193 was sold out. I eventual got around to reading it through certain avenues of the internet, and I absolutely loved the resolution. It felt like a perfect end to the comic series.
​
AMC would come out in the next days and say that they had no plans on ending the television series, though its lead, Andrew Lincoln, had departed in November of the previous year. But as it seemed, The Walking Dead TV series would go on forever. And while Robert Kirkman always said that about the comics, those eventual ended. So too has the TV series. And in January of 2023 I finished season 11C thus ending my twelve year relationship with the series.
But did it actually end? As I write this the main television series has ended and Fear The Walking Dead, the first spin-off of the show, is on its final season. However, as hardcore fans know, a plethora of spin-offs are on their way, led by long-time comic and TV characters: Rick, Michonne, Maggie, and Negan, and probably some other shows that I am not privy to. While nice in theory, these are the very reasons the show ran out of steam during its run. The initial problem that plagued The Walking Dead and the reason it fell from a Darabont slam-dunk into a below average AMC series, connects deeply back to the modern media landscapes. Spin-offs, web-series, and post-episode talk shows are precisely the reason The Walking Dead TV Series pales in comparison to the original comic run.
Before I get into my critical analysis on the show that changed my life, there is a lot to appreciate about the series. The casting of the series from season 1 to season 11 is nearly perfect, with one very notable exception. The castings of Rick Grimes, Maggie, Michonne, Princess, and Mercer, among many others, is a huge reason for the show’s success. Even in episodes and seasons that are far from well-written, these castings help elevate the scripts in the show.
The show in limited seasons is also very well shot. Season 1 and 2 are pretty cinematic, while Seasons 3-5 have a lot of good moments. With Angela Kang taking over for the final few seasons(9-11C) really elevated a lot of the most difficult times in the show’s history. I recall many of the shot compositions from the latter series, while I can only recall the near unwatchable final battle of the All Out War arc which consisted of a final battle on a boring field.
Finally, the most obvious perk of the show is the make-up by Greg Nicotero. Just as Charlie Adler’s drawings added depth to the comics, Nicotero’s make-up is a main reason the show felt so real and was so interesting in comparison to the crazy amount of zombie media that was out at the time. Walkers felt lived in. The first few seasons have very memorable zombies. There is bicycle girl and the little zombie girl from the first episode, well walker in season two, and the tragic Merle zombie at the end of season 3.
​
While The Walking Dead was king of zombie media, the media surrounding it is a huge reason for the shows drop in quality and, overall, the reason the show lacks a cohesive voice or vision and, in contrast, the comics does this in stride. The comic has clear arcs for everyone of its main characters. Rick, Andrea, Carl, Glenn, and Negan have some all-time great storylines throughout the comic. While I find concepts in a lot of the seasons interesting, there are a lot of character beats that are repeated. Carol and Morgan bouncing back and forth between killing everyone or killing no-one to Carl randomly becoming a pacifist before he dies, a lot of these arcs are good in theory, but viewing them as a whole makes the entire series feel like wasted potential. To contrast the comics, nearly every characters store accumulate in a surprising and interesting way. Some of which do not end with a giant explosion, but a sincerity that is deeply lacking in the adaption.
This insincerity stems from AMC’s focus on trying to create a show that was not focused on character, but focused on the universe. They were focused on making The Walking Dead Cinematic Universe(TWDCU), when they should have been focused on making a faithful adaptation about humanity at the end of the world. The first two seasons mostly do this, but as the show goes on it tries to expand an unexpandable universe.
Robert Kirkman once said that his zombie series was not about Rick Grimes, he also said pitched it as a sci-fi epic, both of these statements were proven false. There was never a sci-fi element in the comics, aside from a few pages at the end of issue #75, and The Walking Dead is actually Rick’s story. At the end of issue #192, Sebastian Milton, angry at Rick for ousting his family, shoots Grimes to death. Carl visits Rick’s room the next day and kills the undead corpse of his father. Later in the issue Carl breaks down as a caravan leaves the Commonwealth to travel back to Alexandria. Michonne comforts the young scared boy as he sadly proclaims, “I can’t go on without him. I can’t do this… Not anymore”(Kirkman, Issue #192). The following final issue of the comic sees a twenty year time jump. The comic series is Carl in the end of the last issue. It cannot go on without him. While the brief check in on the characters is very nice, there is no reason to go on with the series without Rick Grimes because it was his story.
So is the failing of the television series due to the departure of Rick Grimes in 2018? Far from it. While the comic series is certainly the story of the Rick Grimes, the television series could have gone on without him, if done properly, and while that is another essay for another time, this particular essay will focus on AMC’s obsession with making the series about the universe as opposed to the characters. Buckle in this is going to be a long one.
​
PART II: THE HEART'S DESIRE
In 2008, Marvel Studios, alongside Paramount Pictures, released Iron Man to critical and commercial success. The film was about an asshole that learns how to have a heart, after nearly dying. Oh and he becomes a superhero. With a surprise appearance by Samuel L. Jackson in a post credit scene, this would kick off the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and in a weird way be the start of the end for The Walking Dead, which was still two years away from airing. However, as the MCU gained popularity by having separate movie franchises culminate into one epic movie, by 2012, after the success of Marvel’s The Avengers, every company was looking for their own universe to make them money.
While this is obviously the point of any large blockbuster or television series, Kevin Feige and co introduced a new concept that would change the cinema landscape forever, similar to George Lucas’ focus on toy rights for his Star Wars films.
So as the MCU began, The Walking Dead did as well and while the first season was successful, the second season had a lower budget and more episodes. In addition a short lived web-series that focused on random characters in TWD universe also was made.
The first was titled “Torn Apart” in 2011, while the second came out in 2012 entitled “Cold Storage.” Both web-series had loose ties to the original series, but started AMC’s attempt to build TWD brand out into a universe. TWDCU for lack of a better term. This also gave make-up artist Greg Nicotero an opportunity to direct. Following those he would eventually direct 37 episodes of the main series.
​
After the departure of Frank Darabont and many cast members that he brought on, the series had a commercially successful run from Seasons 3-5. This would prove to be the very peak of the series. This was must watch TV at the time and mostly everyone tuned in every Sunday at 9pm to watch the show. Rick, Daryl, and Michonne were all household names. During this peak, a spin-off series called Fear the Walking Dead was introduced.
The idea was to have a view from the west coast of the zombie apocalypse, and many believed the two series would eventual crossover, but that never happened. Though, if FTWD was more successful, I am sure AMC would have built up to the ultimate crossover for TWDCU. However, the two series would merge in a very different way after both of them started to stumble.
A several years later, following Season 8 of The Walking Dead and Season 5 of Fear The Walking Dead, the main series would give its own spin-off two vital characters. The two characters of Dwight and Morgan. The latter being the very first survivor that Rick encountered in both incarnations of the story. This would take out two integral characters to Rick’s story. While Rick himself would be leaving the series later on in Season 9. Both Dwight and Morgan serve different aspects to Rick Grimes and would have made the end of the series far more interesting, but as it stands, neither characters’ arcs were fully realized. Leaving both characters with unresolved stories within the main timeline of The Walking Dead.
Dwight’s connection to Rick and the show is more comic based. Dwight in the comics has a much more vital role to the overall story. He is a character that is mostly based on Daryl from the TV show, by appearance, and in an unfortunate turn, many from the production team felt that since the show had Daryl, Dwight felt a bit repetitive. And while that is understandable, Dwight’s role in the comic helps Rick’s arc which in turn is the entire series.
Dwight’s death in the comics is both shocking and heartbreaking. While Rick is the one to pull the trigger, the real gut punch is not that he killed Dwight, but that he had to kill Dwight in this particular moment. Dwight becomes a loose canon in the comics and while Rick disagrees with a lot of Governor Milton’s ideology, it was not the proper time to strike. As a leader, he knows that it is more important for Milton to die at the hands of her people symbolically, rather than dealing with how every villain is dealt with in the TV show, by simply killing them.
Rick’s arc and the comic series in its whole is the story of one man jump starting the new world after the apocalypse. His story from the beginning to the end, and while Dwight is not that character, he is vital to Rick as a leader and character. Without him in the later seasons due to them spinning him off into Fear the Walking Dead, makes Rick’s story far less interesting due to the fact that they literally can’t kill any character.
That is a deep problem with the show after Rick leaves in Season 9. Just about every single big character is essentially safe. However, in the comics it truly feels like no character is ever safe. Later on in the comics following “All Out War,” there is a real feeling of uncertainty with any one of our main characters. Rosita, Ezekiel, Andrea, and Dwight are all gigantic characters that do no make it out of the series alive. But in the show I think Rosita is the only character in the last three seasons that can be characterized as a “big death.” Which is not to say that the story always has to have big deaths, but they should have important deaths that tie deeply into the purpose of the story as well as character’s own stories. In many ways after Andrea’s death in the comics everyone was sad and upset. Even Kirkman himself penned a eulogy for the character. This is all to say that sometimes you have to kill a character for the other character’s sake. There is no hard decisions at the end of The Walking Dead TV series. Everything feel safe because there are many many spin-offs on the way. Dwight was another comic character that had to die to fulfill Rick’s arc at the Commonwealth.
Morgan is another character that is missing in the last few seasons. Morgan’s initial arc with Rick is just about picture perfect. They both meet each other at the beginning, Morgan just lost his wife Jenny, but he still has his son Duane. To contrast, Rick stumbles upon the father and son duo while wandering out of the hospital he’s been in for months. These are the first people that Rick as well as the audience meet in present time. Throughout Season 1, Rick talks to Morgan on a walkie talkie, simply to keep him in the loop, but it also serves as a fun narration piece for Rick in some episodes.
Their next meeting happens in Season 3 Episode 12 entitled “Clear.” Now Rick is the one with his son, but recently lost his wife. Morgan is in this insane “clear” state because he lost Duane in between seasons. Rick is basically in the shoes that Morgan was in at the start of the series and perhaps Morgan is a cautionary tale for Rick as the series goes on. Or they are two sides of the same coin that meet each other at notable moments in their lives. The point is that Rick and Morgan are foils for one another. They serve to show what happens to family men during the end of days.
The final time the two meet is at the end of Season 5. Throughout the season there are flashes of Morgan’s journey toward Rick’s group. It seems as if he is a very different person. The climatic fifth season ends with Rick executing Pete in front of the people of Alexandria, a new town that Rick’s group or the Survivors reside. BLAM. Pete is dead. “Rick?” a cautious Morgan whispers. The cowboy covered in blood turns to see Morgan, the first person he met in the apocalypse. Morgan now at peace and Rick showing what the world can do to you. The series could end right there for the two characters, but their stories go on.
In a lot of ways these three meetings serve as an arc for the show as a whole and more impressively for the characters of Rick and Morgan. It is pretty perfect. This is exactly what you want from the series. However, as it goes on Morgan flips back and forth and rarely has scenes with Rick going into Season 6 and beyond. Morgan and Carol more or less become a duo that lives at the Kingdom, while Rick leads Alexandria.
The comics on the other hand actually struggle with the reintroduction of Morgan. He has a relationship with Michonne, and his death means little in the grand scheme of things. However, the series had the opportunity to do something with Rick and Morgan, even Morgan possibly taking Dwight’s comic role could have been interesting. And provide a nice end to Rick and Morgan’s story. With the main question being “Do the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few?” “What does it take to be a good leader?” Or lastly, “Can you be a good leader and be good to your friends?”
On a related note, Lennie James is one of the best actors The Walking Dead had and he wanted top be on the show even more than he was, so AMC eventually spun him off into FTWD so he could be a lead characters as opposed to supporting which is what he became in TWD.
The characters that had the most potential in the series have always been Rick and Morgan, and if the two actors had stayed in the series, it could have continued to be really special. Especially if they focused on that relationship.
Morgan’s reintroduction was doomed from the start. Not having an incredibly clear story when he is reintroduced in the comics, did not help his TV series counterpart. The writers developed a new story for the character. Morgan is not so much a character when he comes back, but a superhero, he even has his own unique weapon, a staff, which he did not have in the comics. Initially this went over very well. Morgan had his own episode in Season 6 Episode 4 entitled “Here’s Not Here.” It has a great guest actor in John Carroll Lynch as Eastman and is overall very well done. But it is hard to look at it in retrospect because instead of focusing on the characters at hand, it focuses on building a universe and making a grounded character more or less a superhero.
Say what you will about Rick in some of the middle seasons, but for the most part he is a human being first, and a killing machine second. A perfect example is when Rick full kills the Claimers on the road in Season 5, part of the cool part of the scene is that he bites someone’s throat and guts a guy, but the actual great part is that he is doing it to save his son Carl. Through everything his goal is clear: Save Carl.
As the seasons went along they truly lost sight of those character beats. The audience likes Morgan because he is just a man, not a superhero. These characters have heart in the comics. They have motivation. They have a purpose to telling the overall story. The characters in the show serve merely to build out a universe and keep up the brand of The Walking Dead. To make it more like the MCU and less like what makes the initial source material so good: It is about one man trying to start the world over again.
​
PART III: TOO FAR GONE
As I watched the final episode, I felt very little for the overall plot, which was the main sentiment throughout the entire run of the final seasons. I felt little for the atmosphere, the writing, and sadly for the characters. In the final section of the final season, 11C a big action sequence begins and AMC introduces the leads of the final fight: Maggie, Daryl, Carol, Father Gabriel, Aaron, Annie(Negan’s new wife introduced in the final season), Negan, and Magna’s group. Unfortunately, this group did not feel like The Walking Dead. It was more so the leftovers of a show that many have parted from. In their final season they would rise up against the rich and spin-off into the sunset.
Following my finale viewing, a tough work out(brag), and a quick shower, I found myself sad. Genuinely. Not because of the episode that I just watched, but because of the years of my life that I had dedicated to this series. As a fan, as a human, and even as an artist. It was impossible for me not to feel anything. It has been a large part of my life for twelve years. Just about half of my life has been devoted to this one zombie story. While I appreciate that about it, it is also tragic that I could not finish it live with everyone else that watched through the years. The actual survivors.
Instead of a celebration with my fellow Walking Dead heads, I ended up waiting months until it was “free” on Netflix. This was the inception of my writing: to find out why I could not care to catch up on my favorite TV series.
When moving to Los Angeles at the beginning of 2021 with the pandemic along with uprooting my life, I watched very little of the series. Looking at the series from an objective perspective, the production quality was still pretty high. Though through it all, something about the characters made the show crumble. Not budget, not hype, just something organic that was lost along the way. That started after the time jump in Season 9 Episode 5.
Following Rick’s departure of the show, the writers did not want to dwell on the implications of the biggest person in the show dying but not dying. It would have been three wasted episodes of mourning Rick, who could possibly come back at any moment if Andrew Lincoln chose to, so having a big time jump to dance around that fact makes a ton of sense. Also this ages up Judith so there is always a constant Grimes in the series, also makes sense. It all makes sense on paper, but the implications water down the earlier story.
This is simply with the timeline. Take Carl Grimes in the TV series for instance. Carl in the comics, not including the twenty year time jump at the end, is roughly 9-14 throughout the run of the comics. While in the show Carl is 12-14, but obviously looks closer to 18 in the show. The issue with this is that from seasons 1-8 the total time spent in series is about two years, but with the 6 year time jump the surviving characters have known each there for 3 times the amount of time that Rick knew them. Essentially the first eight seasons almost become meaningless because of this. Not that it matters all that much, but Michonne has known Rick for roughly two and a half years, but has known Daryl for nearly eight and a half. Once you start thinking about it, the time in the first few seasons seems meaningless. Michonne rarely discusses the Governor, her family before, and Andrea, a character she shared a good portion of Season 3 with.
It starts to feel like these characters should be over these deaths because no one brings up Sasha, Tyreese, Beth, or any of the Alexandrians literally the following seasons and episodes after their deaths. That is simply what the show sets up before the 6-year time jump. People die in the series and then six months later are never discussed again. But somehow Rick, The War with Negan, and basically everything to happen right before the time jump is still being discussed six years later. I understand the decisions made, but it started to feel as if the rest of the series did not matter because of it. A random character such as Siddiq(Seasons 8-10), who is in the series before and after the total seven and a half year time jump, has known Michonne for a lot longer than Rick ever knew her. Again this is not to say that it is the biggest issue of the show, but it is a huge reason why viewers slowly began to fall off. From a story perspective, obviously Rick is important and the whole point of the time jump is to make Judith an actual character instead of just a baby, but it is hard not to think about how small the entire first eight seasons feel when there is a time jump that is three times the amount of time in the first eight seasons. I could go on about which random characters knew each other for nearly a decade or how insignificant Rick’s story becomes in the TV series, but there are more reasons the series fell flat by the end.
Following the six year time jump, the Whisperers are introduced. One of the most innovative and interesting groups in the comics were to make their debut following Rick’s departure. They were introduced pretty well in the episodes leading up to the midseason finale, even killing off a survivor of the comic series, who was poorly used in the adaptation. After that the leader of Whisperers, Alpha, played by Samantha Morton, was introduced. This is, in my opinion, the biggest miscast in the shows history, and a main reason people ended up falling off. While Alpha is very well realized in the comics, in the show she is very different. This has to do with a mixture of a misreading of the comics and an incredibly over the top performance based in that misunderstanding.
There are millions of comic books out there. Each one has their own stories and characters and purposes. Batman is a dark character later on in his comic run. The 1960’s show is a good adaption of the initial 30’s Batman comics. It is campy and fun. Every Batman of the 2000’s is essentially an adaption of Batman’s darker stories. The Killing Joke, The Dark Knight Returns, and A Death in the Family are a few comics that have inspired and been adapted for Batman in the 21st century. The beauty of these comics is that they are dark, but also that the comic art gives the best performances that one can imagine. Ledger read comics to create his Joker. He developed that kind of Joker while reading the comics. People now read the Joker as his interpretation of the character. Comics are imaginative and anyone can dream of the best representation of any character. Alpha is a character that is very difficult to understand solely based on the comics, and I believe Samantha Morton, the writers, directors, and Angela Kang read Alpha incorrectly.
This is not to say that the writing is horrible for Alpha, but if you build your skyscraper on a faulty foundation, it will crumble. I read Alpha in the books as being stoic and driven. She has reached a point in her life where names do not matter and all that matters is survival, and for a post-apocalyptic world this makes a lot of sense. She is also intelligent. Kirkman created a few issues in the comics where I genuinely thought the walkers were talking to each other. That is the only thing that made sense, but the beauty of the twist is that it is people that disguise themselves as walkers. It is a perfect turn for the series and a concept that is clearly utilized by our survivors in the early issues of the comics and episodes of the show. The old guts trick. However it takes it a step further by literally skinning zombies and using their skin as protection.
This is not the idea of someone who is insane. In the TV Series, Morton and Kang’s version of Alpha is simply a crazy person. This person snaps and dresses like a zombie now. Apparently there is also a backstory for Alpha in the Tales from the Walking Dead spinoff, that shows Alpha coming across the Whisperers, but I always had the thought that Alpha was the one to create the idea of the Whisperers. I digress. While Alpha being insane and creepy is good in theory, I personally think Alpha being more pragmatic sells the story better.
The first page where Alpha reveals her face in the comics is shocking. She is clean and bald, she even looks somewhat shiny in the first comic panel she is in. She looks like a normal person. Typically in the universe villains are gross and in the TV show and comics almost all of them are. The Governor, Negan, the Hunters/Termites, basically all the villains are presented as gross, but not comic book Alpha. She is clean. She is driven. I always felt that, when compared to Batman villains, Alpha is more akin to Mr. Freeze rather than the Joker. Alpha’s story is more tragic than someone that has lost their mind and talks in a whispered southern accent.
She is someone that is smart and wants to survive at all costs. Even if it means losing her daughter. In the comics a lot more people challenge Alpha and she constantly destroys them. There is a stoic nature to all of this. The fact that she basically has turned her back on all earthly desires isn’t necessarily crazy as it is determined for one goal: Survival. It’s an incredibly rich character that is hidden by the walker costumes that she wears. She is emotionless. She is stoic. She is driven. This all changes when Negan joins the Whisperers. She holds this primal exterior for a good portion of their time together, but when Negan breaks down that exterior, the reader, for the first time sees the real Alpha. She cries and is human. It makes it so shocking. For all of these issues, she has never truly shown any emotion and this beat is so interesting for both her and Negan. The new Whisperer Negan holds Alpha in his arms. He has broken down her survival instincts and the reader sees a human for the first time. The two look at each other. Alpha leans in for a kiss and then… Negan slits her throat and cuts off her head. The whole issue is shocking but the most shocking part is that Alpha let her guard down.
This is different in the show. Alpha shows her emotions on her sleeves because that’s exactly what the character is: unhinged. She is completely a wreck and the audience can easily see all of it. I typically read Alpha as someone that had a really great poker face. There was never a moment where you could see what she was actually thinking. When she shows Rick the walker horde in the comics it feels like she is showing him and stating facts. She always felt like that. Her whole ideology is that the ones that survive are “the strong.” This does not mean the series had to do any of that. Most of the first season is not exactly what happens on the comics, but it expands on a concept like Rick, Lori, and Shane’s love triangle. Alpha should have had some sort of resemblance to her comic counterpart and then the writers could expand from there.
A similar mis-reading happens in the final season with the Commonwealth and ties in with the problem of modern media. In a show about zombies killing people, it is clear that the 2020 BLM protests had an effect on the writing of the final season. While I think those protests were justified and I attended many, I do not believe any good came from its inclusion in the final season of the main series. If writers are adding social commentary it should make sense with the world and the universe they are creating. In the Walking Dead’s entire run the only people that have been treated differently are the undead. It is a huge head scratcher to add in the final season of a series that has never discussed issues like this. It does not tie in with a sort of racial inequality but seeks to stand for equality from different financial classes. Nothing similar to this happens in the comics and everything they add with the Commonwealth makes little sense. A big part of that is the class structure.
In the comics it is simply put that the survivors must act on Pamela at the proper time. There is no big fight at the end, but simply Rick speaking to the people of the Commonwealth and telling them that they deserve a better future that they can create. They do not have to be ruled by someone that doesn’t have their best interest, and through that Rick becomes a legend. However, in the show there is no Rick so they had to stretch Pamela Milton’s evilness more and it comes off as incredibly questionable for a civilization that has been destroyed for nearly a decade. Why do they care about money still? How do they have money? Why do they end it with battles? I just felt the last season was less influenced by the comics and more influenced by the modern landscape. Including wage gaps, protests, and literally Two-Face. They just make Lance Two-Face which was both frustrating and annoying. Josh Hamilton as Lance was really good though. The main problem with this whole arc is that is simultaneously focuses on connecting to the current world problems as well as repeating the same story that the TV series always does: They get to a new place, people are bad, then they either have to leave or make it better. That’s basically every arc in The Walking Dead.
To contrast, the comics do a really good job at mixing up each other the beats, while the TV series streamlines every beat. This is what happens with each new place in the books vs the show: 1) Atlanta is pretty much the same. 2)The Farm is destroyed in the show, while in the comics it is not and they simply find the prison. 3) The Prison is destroyed in both. 4) Terminus is destroyed, while in the comics they simply go back to the farm and then run into Eugene and start heading toward DC. 5) Alexandria is more or less there home in both for the rest, though in the show Hilltop, Alexandria, and the Kingdom all are destroyed at one point. 5) Commonwealth in the show is mostly destroyed, while nothing like that happens in the comics and they simply leave.
While mostly the same, nearly every camp is destroyed in the show somehow which gets very repetitive. Overall, through some misreadings and a focus on the modern universe building machine, The Walking Dead’s final season felt more like a jumbled trailer than an actual cohesive end.
​
PART IV: REST IN PEACE
After writing these pages on one of my favorite stories of all time, I find the main reason for The Walking Dead’s failures was the lack of a cohesive vision. At the end of the day, for a piece of media to speak to me, and for others I hope, it has to have some sort of greater purpose. Even in comedy or action, there should be some vision. Unfortunately, the events leading up to the “end” of the series are deeply rooted in a need and a want by AMC to build a universe rather than one large story.
The comic books had a simple purpose: One man’s journey of rebuilding society through the apocalypse. The television series is much different. I suppose you can say a lot of things that the show does, but none of it is actually for a greater purpose. This is not the fault of any one show runner as each subsequent one had to somehow recreate the show through following the departure of the previous show runner.
Glen Mazzara had probably the toughest job out of any of the replacements as Frank Darabont was fired. Mazzara’s era will certainly be remembered for the slowness of Season 2 followed by the break neck speed of season 3. Mazzara also had to balance an unhappy cast with Jon Bernthal(Shane), Sarah Wayne Callies(Lori), Jeffery Duhman(Dale), and Laurie Holden(Andrea), all still having loyalty to the man that brought all of them into those roles, and had previously worked with them, Frank Darabont. All of those actors would be out of jobs by the end of the third season of the show.
Scott Gimple then took control during the golden and the less than golden age of the series. His five seasons saw the absolute peak of the series, but everything eventually caught up and his reign as show runner is a huge reason for the difficult job producing a cohesive vision by the end. Gimple was show runner for the beloved season 4 and season 5, the mixed bags that were seasons 6 and 7, and finally the widely regarded mess: season 8.
Gimple suffered from a similar focus on “shocking deaths” as the seasons went along. While Game of Thrones was shockingly killing off cast members, The Walking Dead began to do that as well, although it quickly became clear that these kills would eventually be a huge reason for the series decline. This included Carl’s death, in some ways Tyreese’s death, and most importantly the double deaths of Glenn. One in season 6 and the other actual death at the start of season 7. Why pretend to kill a character for 4 episodes to have him come back and then actually kill him at the beginning of the next season? Season 8 would also take one of the best comic story lines and regress it to mostly people shooting blindly in dull gray factory buildings.
Finally, Angela Kang did her best to salvage the series while Andrew Lincoln(Rick), Danai Gurira(Michonne), Lauren Cohen(Maggie), and Chandler Riggs(Carl Grimes) all left the series to pursue other roles, while the latter was killed off in season 8.
All of these different visions and “shocking” deaths made it so the final season really could not kill any one and even spared many of the surprising deaths in the comics. Long live the king, but at the end of the day the series lacked a clear vision and purpose for their deaths. Say what you will about the end of Game of Thrones but just about every character death throughout the series served a purpose for other characters and the story as a whole. While The Walking Dead prided itself on this same concept, there were so little characters at the end of the series that the true final surprise of The Walking Dead came in season 9 episode 15 “The Calm Before.” Even that is not as shocking as that comic book arc. Even Negan killing Alpha felt so obvious. There was seemingly no tense as the series concluded which is disappointing of a series built on that tension. That not only is due the lack of deaths, but also the spin-off shows coming out.
Simply put, the final season of The Walking Dead is not the end of the story. It is simply the end of this chapter. A show should have chapters in their seasons. A viewer of a twelve year old series should feel some sort of satisfaction by the end of it. But that is just how modern media is now. Everything has to simultaneously be a story and a promotion for the next installment in the universe. While this could certainly be the MCU’s fault and the fault of audience goers to make that franchise the most commercially successful film project ever, it is more the fault of the producers of The Walking Dead. The series should not have focused on what was big at the time. Shocking deaths, endless spin-offs, and a product that is just that: a product. It could have focused on the simplest part of the comic series: Rick Grimes. It could have focused on telling a cohesive story. They could have made spin-offs that added to the story or stayed far away from the story. Instead all of it built up to an absolutely incoherent story that has little resemblance to the first season, both in character and purpose.
The Walking Dead will always be special to me. However, as something helps you grow you also have to let it go. It changed and that is okay. Not everything can always be what it was. It has helped me a lot and I will never forget that. So thank you Robert Kirkman, Frank Darabont, Glen Marzzara, Scott Gimple, Angela Kang, and everyone else involved in the series for creating something that made me analyze and think about what I was watching. It gave me tools to see how important writing and filmmaking are when adapting media. While the comics always will be great, I was never blinded into thinking that the show had to be exactly like it.
In my youth, I did not understand what made season 1 so good, but looking back it is easily the “best” season in my eyes. Darabont had a clear vision of what he wanted out of the series. It was not going to be exactly like the comics, but an adaptation that is very much expanding on the source material. Shane, the CDC, and the plans he had for season 2 are perfect examples of how he was planning to expand the universe within the contexts of the show.
The one and only show.
Storytellers like Darabont are not made for the modern media landscape. Social media and quick turnarounds doom a show that is trying to do something special. I am sure Darabont would have checked in on other places in the world. He had an idea for the backstory for the walker Sam Whiter played in the very first episode. While I can spend hours thinking of the story he creates, it simply is not made for the modern media landscapes.
Not many groundbreaking stories are made for the modern era, and maybe that is okay.